YouTube to remove some clips mocking Thai king

Video-sharing Web site YouTube has agreed to block four clipsThailand says insulted its revered king, the latest twist in a spat

that has stirred fierce debate about freedom of expression on the
Internet.

However, in a letter to Communications Minister Sitthichai Pookaiyaudom, YouTube owner Google said two other videos that had incurred the wrath of Thailand’s military government would stay as they did not break lese-majeste laws, which cover insults to the dignity of the king.

“They appear to be political comments that are critical of both the government and the conduct of foreigners,” the letter said.

“Because they are political in nature, and not intended insults of His
Majesty, we do not see a basis for blocking these videos.”

Insulting royalty is a serious offense in Thailand, but the generals
who ousted Prime Minister Thaksin Shinawatra in a military coup in
September have also used the strict lese-majeste laws to stifle
criticism of themselves and their actions.

Sitthichai, who blocked the entire YouTube Web site last month when clips mocking King Bhumibol Adulyadej first appeared, gave copies of the letter to reporters on Friday.

The letter was printed on Google letterhead and signed by senior
company lawyer Kent Walker. The company could not immediately be
reached for comment.

The letter said Thailand had sent YouTube bosses a list of 12 video

clips it deemed offensive. Six of the clips had already been removed by
their creators or because they violated YouTube’s “code of service.”
Sitthichai, who threatened to sue Google earlier in the week, said he no longer wished to take legal action but did not say whether the company’s concession was enough for him unblock YouTube for Thai Internet surfers.

“The Thai police will not take any action against any company. Instead
they will look into ways of fighting the person who uploaded the video
onto the Web site,” he told a news conference.

The first king-bashing clip appeared a few days after a 57-year-old
Swiss man received a 10-year jail sentence for spraying graffiti on
pictures of the king on his birthday in December. It was a rare
conviction of a foreigner.

Bhumibol, the world’s longest-reigning monarch, has been on the throne
for more than 60 years, has since granted a pardon to the Swiss man,
who has been deported.

YouTube to remove some clips mocking Thai king
ZDNet - 1 hour ago
Video-sharing
Web site YouTube has agreed to block four clips Thailand says insulted
its revered king, the latest twist in a spat that has stirred fierce …

Thailand drops plan to sue Google USA Today - 2 hours ago BANGKOK, Thailand (AP) — The Thai government abruptly scrapped plans to sue Google after the US company agreed to remove from a website video clips deemed …

Google to Remove YouTube Clips Techtree.com, India - 4 hours ago In what looks like the end of a month-long slugfest between Google and the Thai government, the Information and Communications Ministry has decided to drop …

YouTube to remove some clips mocking Thai king Reuters India, India - 5 hours ago By Mei Vandenberghe. BANGKOK (Reuters) - Video-sharing Web site YouTube has agreed to block four clips Thailand says insulted its revered king, …

YouTube to remove clips mocking king The Australian, Australia - 5 hours ago By Mei Vandenberghe in Bangkok. VIDEO-sharing Web site YouTube has agreed to block four clips Thailand says insulted its revered king, the latest twist in a …

Thailand Drops Plan To Sue Google Guardian Unlimited, UK - 5 hours ago From AP. AP Photo TOK103. BANGKOK, Thailand (AP) - The Thai government abruptly scrapped plans to sue Google after the US company agreed to remove from a …

Thailand Drops Plan to Sue Google Los Angeles Times, CA - 6 hours ago By AP. BANGKOK, Thailand — The Thai government abruptly scrapped plans to sue Google after the US company agreed to remove from a Web site video clips …

Thailand Drops Plan to Sue Google Forbes, NY - 6 hours ago AP 05.11.07, 3:32 AM ET. The Thai government abruptly scrapped plans to sue Google after the US company agreed to remove from a Web site video clips deemed …

Govt drops Google lawsuit Bangkok Post, Thailand - 11 hours ago The Information and Communications Ministry has dropped the criminal lawsuit it planned to file against Google today after the internet giant officially …

YouTube bows to Thai king Sydney Morning Herald, Australia - 11 hours ago YouTube is likely to remove all video clips deemed insulting to Thailand’s king, a government official said today, paving the way to the ban on the website …

Thais sue YouTube over royal ‘insult’ The Age, Australia - May 9, 2007 Thailand’s army-backed government plans to sue internet video-sharing site YouTube over clips it deemed insulting to King Bhumibol Adulyadej. …

Thailand Drops Plan to Sue Google TMC Net, CT - 43 minutes ago The Thai government abruptly scrapped plans to sue Google after the US company agreed to remove from a Web site video clips deemed insulting to the …

ICT Ministry drops plan to sue Google Thai News Agency MCOT, Thailand - 2 hours ago Mr. Sitthichai said Google’s vice president Kent Walker sent a letter to the ministry Thursday stating that his company intended to remove all the …

Thai govt threatens YouTube users over king videos Nation Multimedia, Thailand - 3 hours ago Thai government said Friday that it had reached an agreement with the video-sharing site YouTube to remove clips deemed insulting to the Thai king, …

Thailand Drops Plan to Sue Google PhysOrg.com, VA - 3 hours ago Thai King Bhumibol Adulyadej arrives at Siriraj Hospital in Bangkok in this July 20, 2006 file photo. The Thai government abruptly scrapped plans to sue …

Thai govt says YouTube to cooperate on removal of king videos Hemscott, UK - 7 hours ago BANGKOK (XFN-ASIA) - The government said that it has reached an agreement with the video-sharing site YouTube to remove clips deemed insulting to the Thai …

Thai govt says YouTube to cooperate on removal of king videos ABCmoney.co.uk, UK - 8 hours ago By : Agencies. BANGKOK (XFN-ASIA) - The government said that it has reached an agreement with the video-sharing site YouTube to remove clips deemed …

Thai Government Drops Suit Against Google TMCnet - 17 hours ago By Pradip Bhatacharya. The Thai government decided Thursday not to sue Google Inc., after the Internet search giant promised to remove all anti-monarchy …

Thailand drops law suit against Google Earthtimes.org - May 10, 2007 Bangkok - The Thai government decided Thursday not to sue Google.Inc after the internet search giant reportedly promised to remove all anti-monarchy videos …

Thais to sue Google over king video MWC News, Canada - May 9, 2007 By Agencies. The Thai government is to sue Google in a criminal court over internet video clips it says are insulting to the king. …

GooTube Faces Royal Headache Top Tech News, CA - May 9, 2007 By Frederick Lane. The Thailand-YouTube dispute centers around video clips posted to YouTube that are said to be disrespectful of Thailand’s King Bhumibol …

Thai information ministry to charge Google People’s Daily Online, China - May 8, 2007 Thailand’s Information and Communications Technology (ICT) Ministry was preparing to file a charge against Google in Thailand after it refused to remove …

YouTube to remove some clips mocking Thai king CNET News.com, CA - 1 hour ago Four clips blocked by Google, but access remains for two that angered Thailand’s military leaders. By Reuters. Video-sharing Web site YouTube has agreed to …

Government demands YouTube reveal user identity Bangkok Post, Thailand - 2 hours ago The latest development came on Friday, just as the kerfuffle over the Internet videos appeared to be dying down and headed for a mutual resolution which …

ICT to sue creators of clips mocking King Bangkok Post, Thailand - 5 hours ago (BangkokPost.com from Agencies) - Information and Communication Technology Ministry threatens to sue the creators of videos mocking His Majesty the King …

Google ‘to remove Thai King videos’ Aljazeera.net, Qatar - 6 hours ago Thailand is to hold off pressing legal charges against Google after it agreed to remove videos deemed offensive to the Thai king from its YouTube website. …

Sittichai says Google blinks Bangkok Post, Thailand - May 10, 2007 By BangkokPost.com, Post Reporters. The government said on Thursday that the search giant has promised to remove all anti-monarchy videos from the …

Get the latest news PR-Inside.com (Pressemitteilung), Austria - 47 minutes ago The Thai government has dropped plans to sue Google, after the internet giant agreed to remove clips deemed insulting to King Bhumibol Adulyadej from one of …

Thai government drops plan to sue Google on video clips People’s Daily Online, China - 3 hours ago Thailand’s Information and Communications Technology (ICT) has dropped a criminal lawsuit it planned to file against Google Inc, the US-based parent company …

Thai government drops plan to sue Google
New Straits Times, Malaysia - 5 hours ago
BANGKOK:
Thailand’s Information and Communications Technology Minister
Sitthichai Pookaiyaudom said here Friday his ministry had dropped a
criminal lawsuit …

Youtube kisses the feet of Thai king
Inquirer, UK - 5 hours ago
By
Nick Farrell: Friday 11 May 2007, 09:41. YOUTUBE is to pull all video
clips from its site which are deemed insulting to Thailand’s king, and
free itself …

Google Sends Apology Letter to Thai Government, Promises to Take … SDA Asia Magazine, Singapore - 11 hours ago In a bid to avoid any lawsuits and hostile feelings, Internet search giant Google has agreed to take down all anti-monarchy videos from its YouTube website. …

Google Apologizes, Thailand Drops Lawsuit WebProNews, KY - 16 hours ago Quite a line was forming up, but it appears there’s now one less organization in the world that wants to sue YouTube; since the video-sharing site decided …

THAILAND: Sittichai says Google blinks Asia Pacific Media Network, CA - 19 hours ago The ICT minister said on Thursday that the search giant has promised to remove all anti-monarchy videos from the YouTube.com website, and has decided not to …

YouTube expected to remove clips of Thai king Daily News & Analysis, India - 23 hours ago BANGKOK: YouTube is likely to remove all video clips deemed insulting to Thailand’s king, a government official said on Thursday, paving the way to the ban …

Thailand to Sue Google Over Offensive YouTube Video Mathaba.Net, UK - May 9, 2007 BANGKOK (mathaba) — The Thai government is to sue Google in a criminal court over internet video clips which were insulting to the His Majesty the King and …

YouTube faces criminal charges Bangkok Recorder, Thailand - May 9, 2007 Thailand’s Information and Communications Technology (ICT) ministry will file Criminal Court charges against Google on Friday, reveals minister Sitthichai …

Thailand joins the queue to sue YouTube TECH.BLORGE.com, Australia - May 8, 2007 Thailand’s Information and Communications Technology Ministry will proceed with a criminal lawsuit against Google over a spate of YouTube-hosted videos that …

Thailand to SueTube YouTube too? iTWire, Australia - May 8, 2007 By Alex Zaharov-Reutt. Thailand’s ICT Minister Sitthichai Pookaiyaudom is reported to be ready to file suit against Google and YouTube on Friday after …

Thailand Lawyers Up In Anti-YouTube Crusade WebProNews, KY - May 8, 2007 About a month ago, the government of Thailand blocked YouTube; all of YouTube was inaccessible in all of Thailand, and the ban has remained in place all …

YouTube Sued By Thai Government
Portal IT, Romania - May 8, 2007
YouTube’s
lawyers are getting plenty of action nowadays. First came Viacom’s
lawsuit, NBC joined the legal fight, and now the Thai government is
also taking …